Do sinners burn forever in hell fire?...

The Origin and History of the
Doctrine of Endless Punishment

by Thomas B. Thayer, New and enlarged edition. Boston: Universalist Publishing House. 1881.

Contents

Preface: Why this book was written.
Chapter I. The Period before the Law of Moses.: No Law announced to our First Parents with the Penalty of Endless Punishments annexed; Not revealed in the History of their Transgression, nor in that of Cain, the Deluge, or Sodom and Gomorrah
Chapter II. The Period under the Law of Moses.: Sect. I. - Endless Punishment not taught by Moses in the Law nor is it mentioned anywhere in the Bible History of the Jews; Sect. II. - Testimony of Orthodox Critics and Theologians to this Point; Sect. III. - Old Testament Doctrine of Hell, Sheol; Sect. IV. - General Application of the Argument; Sect. V. - Objections to the foregoing Argument answered
Chapter III. Endless Punishment of Heathen Origin.: Sect. I. - Description of the Heathen Hell, its Location, Inhabitants, and Punishments; compared with Church Doctrines; Sect. II. - The Doctrine invented by Heathen Legislators and Poets; shown by their own Confession. Its Egyptian Origin
Chapter IV. The Jews Borrowed the Doctrine from the Heathen.: The Historical Argument on this Point
Chapter V. Endless Punishment Not Taught in the New Testament.: Sect I. -Salvation of Christ not from this; Sect. II. - New Testament Doctrine of Hell; Sect. III. - Unquenchable Fire; how used in the Scriptures; how used by Greek Writers; Sect. IV. - Everlasting, Eternal and Forever, not Endless
: Testimony of Lexicographers and Critics; Usage of Greek Authors; Scripture Usage; Sect. V. - The Second Death
Chapter VI. The Introduction of the Doctrine into the Christian Church: The general Corruption of the early Church; First Appearance of the Doctrine - its Form; First, The Wicked not raised from the Dead, or Underworld; Second, Raised and Punished; Third, Future Punishment ending in Annihilation; Fourth, Endless Punishment; Condemnation of Universalism, and Endless Punishment decreed Orthodox, A. D. 553
Chapter VII. The Doctrine Creates a Cruel and Revengeful Spirit - Illustrated from History.: Influence of Faith on Character; Tertullian's Exultation; Catholic Crusades against the Albigenses; Massacre of St. Bartholomew; The Catholic Inquisition; The Spanish Inquisition; its Influence on Society; The Influence not confined to Catholic Believers of the Doctrine
Chapter VIII. The Comparative Moral Influence of Belief and Disbelief in Endless Punishment - Historical Contrast.: Its Influence on the Morals of the Heathen; Greeks, Romans, Burmans; The Character of the Pharisees and Sadducees contrasted in reference to this Point
Chapter IX. The Influence of the Doctrine on the Happiness of its Believers - Illustrated from their own Confessions.: Testimony of Saurin, Stuart, Barnes, Henry Ward Beecher, etc.
Chapter X. Additional Testimonies on the Questions Discussed in the Preceding Chapters.

Prove all things - hold fast that which is good. - PAUL.

PREFACE.

Thomas B. Thayer, 1881: This little work is written for the purpose of furnishing a sketch of the argument by which it is shown that the doctrine of Endless Punishment is not of divine origin, but traceable directly to a heathen source.

It is not intended as an elaborately philosophical or critical discussion of the subject, as the size of the volume will show; but only as a popular presentation of the method of proof, and of the leading facts and authorities on which the argument rests.

Those having time and the sources of information at command, will enter into a more thorough investigation for themselves. For such this work is not designed; but for those who, not having the opportunity, nor the books, necessary to a complete and critical examination of the question, wish a brief statement of the facts and arguments on which is grounded the assertion that the doctrine of endless torments is of heathen origin.

This will account for the absence of many things which the reader might justly expect to find here, and which rightfully claim place in a work bearing the title of this.

The subject treated is one of very great importance, and equally concerns the purity of Christian doctrine, and the happiness and virtue of those believing. It is every day commanding more and more attention from serious and thoughtful minds. And on all sides, and in the churches of all sects, there is increased inquiry into the foundations of the doctrine, and rapidly growing doubts of its divine origin and authority. It is possible the following pages may help to answer some of the questions growing out of this state of mind, and to show how a doctrine, thoroughly heathen in origin and character, came to be adopted by the Christian church.

The sale of the first edition of nearly two thousand copies in the space of three or four months [1855], without being advertised in any form, has encouraged me to believe that the work meets an actual want, and will be serviceable to the cause of Truth. In the preparation of the present edition, therefore, I have made considerable additions; and, I trust, improvements also, in the hope of making it more worthy and more useful. Two chapters and two sections entire have been added, and chapters three, four and six, have been greatly enlarged, and the argument illustrated and fortified by new facts and authorities.

Still the book is far from being what I could wish, or what it might be made, if time, and all the means of investigation, were at command. Yet, such as it is, I send it forth again, to do what work it may; believing that, in the conflict of opinions, Truth only is immortal, and cheerfully confident, therefore, that, at last, all error and all evil will perish.

Since the above was written, this work has passed through several large editions. The present issue has additional testimonies strengthening the argument in its various branches. Most of these, with the exception of those pertaining to Chapters III. and IX., which are inserted in the body of the text, are gathered into a single chapter at the end of the book; and to facilitate reference, notes have been added to the chapters and sections to which they severally belong.

Boston, January, 1871.

The Origin and History of the Doctrine of Endless Punishment, Thomas B. Thayer, Boston, 1881
Preface
Chapter I. The Period before the Law of Moses.
Chapter II. The Period under the Law of Moses.
Chapter III. Endless Punishment of Heathen Origin.
Chapter IV. The Jews Borrowed the Doctrine from the Heathen.
Chapter V. Endless Punishment Not Taught in the New Testament.
Chapter VI. The Introduction of the Doctrine into the Christian Church.
Chapter VII. The Doctrine Creates a Cruel and Revengeful Spirit - Illustrated from History.
Chapter VIII. The Comparative Moral Influence of Belief and Disbelief in Endless Punishment - Historical Contrast.
Chapter IX. The Influence of the Doctrine on the Happiness of its Believers - Illustrated from their own Confessions.
Chapter X. Additional Testimonies on the Questions Discussed in the Preceding Chapters.

Go to Literature Index Page

This URL is abcog.org/thayer.htm